Schlotzsky's · Updated Jul 31, 2026
Real fan builds and custom orders — estimated US-average prices and exactly how to ask for each one.
These Schlotzsky's orders are built from standard menu items — not a printed secret sheet. Each card includes what to say, difficulty, and an estimated price range.
Ask for any sandwich built on Spicy Bread with Schlotzsky's Hot Sauce, pickled jalapeños and pepper jack — the spice-lover swap
Say: “Can I get Spicy Original (Hot Sauce Swap) with Ask for any sandwich built on Spicy Bread with Schlotzsky's Hot Sauce, pickled jalapeños and pepper jack — the spice-lover swap?”
Most locations recognize this customization routinely.
Est. $9.49 · verify at checkout
Order the small Garden Salad and ask for 3 slices of warm focaccia/pesto bread on the side — the under-$5 lunch trick
Say: “Can I get The $2 Bread-Basket Salad (Cheap Lunch Hack) with Order the small Garden Salad and ask for 3 slices of warm focaccia/pesto bread on the side — the under-$5 lunch trick?”
Staff may need a moment to build this — order during off-peak if possible.
Est. $4.49 · verify at checkout
The Original + smoked bacon, extra cheddar and provolone, chipotle sauce, double-toasted — ask for it 'smokecheesy'
Say: “Can I get Bacon Smokecheesy Melt with The Original + smoked bacon, extra cheddar and provolone, chipotle sauce, double-toasted — ask for it 'smokecheesy'?”
Staff may need a moment to build this — order during off-peak if possible.
Est. $11.99 · verify at checkout
Turkey Original swapped onto toasted Dark Rye with Swiss, spicy brown mustard and extra pickles
Say: “Can I get Turkey Rye Melt with Turkey Original swapped onto toasted Dark Rye with Swiss, spicy brown mustard and extra pickles?”
Extra modifications may add to wait time and price.
Est. $10.29 · verify at checkout
Build any sandwich on Jalapeño Cheese Bread with pepper jack, fresh + pickled jalapeños and chipotle mayo
Say: “Can I get Jalapeño Cheese Bread Fiesta with Build any sandwich on Jalapeño Cheese Bread with pepper jack, fresh + pickled jalapeños and chipotle mayo?”
Most locations recognize this customization routinely.
Est. $10.79 · verify at checkout
Order a personal Pepperoni and Double-Cheese flatbread pizza and ask them to fold and press it like a sandwich
Say: “Can I get The Folded Flatbread (Pizza-wich) with Order a personal Pepperoni and Double-Cheese flatbread pizza and ask them to fold and press it like a sandwich?”
Staff may need a moment to build this — order during off-peak if possible.
Est. $9.29 · verify at checkout
The Original with added avocado, extra Dijon and loaded lettuce/tomato — ask 'loaded, add avocado'
Say: “Can I get Avocado Original with The Original with added avocado, extra Dijon and loaded lettuce/tomato — ask 'loaded, add avocado'?”
Extra modifications may add to wait time and price.
Est. $10.49 · verify at checkout
Grilled or crispy chicken tossed in hot sauce with pepper jack, ranch and extra lettuce on toasted sourdough
Say: “Can I get Buffalo Chicken Bomb with Grilled or crispy chicken tossed in hot sauce with pepper jack, ranch and extra lettuce on toasted sourdough?”
Extra modifications may add to wait time and price.
Est. $10.99 · verify at checkout
Order a cup of Broccoli Cheese soup plus a bag of chips and use the soup as a warm dip — cheap combo hack
Say: “Can I get Broccoli-Cheese Chip Dip Combo with Order a cup of Broccoli Cheese soup plus a bag of chips and use the soup as a warm dip — cheap combo hack?”
Staff may need a moment to build this — order during off-peak if possible.
Est. $6.79 · verify at checkout
Ask for a wrap with double turkey, bacon, avocado, cheddar and ranch — the 'loaded club' wrap
Say: “Can I get Double-Turkey Bacon Ranch Wrap with Ask for a wrap with double turkey, bacon, avocado, cheddar and ranch — the 'loaded club' wrap?”
Staff may need a moment to build this — order during off-peak if possible.
Est. $9.99 · verify at checkout
At Cinnabon co-branded stores: two warm chocolate-chip cookies with Cinnabon cream-cheese frosting spread between — ask nicely
Say: “Can I get Cinnabon Frosting Cookie Sandwich (Co-Located Stores) with At Cinnabon co-branded stores: two warm chocolate-chip cookies with Cinnabon cream-cheese frosting spread between — ask nicely?”
Most locations recognize this customization routinely.
Est. $5.49 · verify at checkout
Order a kids cheese flatbread pizza plus a side of Cinnabon frosting to dip the crust — sweet-and-savory hack
Say: “Can I get Kids Pizza + Frosting Dip with Order a kids cheese flatbread pizza plus a side of Cinnabon frosting to dip the crust — sweet-and-savory hack?”
Staff may need a moment to build this — order during off-peak if possible.
Est. $6.29 · verify at checkout
Start from the regular Schlotzsky's menu — entree, combo, or side.
Read the phrase on each card, or enter the same modifiers in the mobile app.
Extras change price and prep time. Verify the total at checkout or the window.
Most Schlotzsky's locations do not publish a formal secret menu. The orders below are community-built customizations staff typically know how to make.
Franchise policies vary. If one store declines, try the mobile app where customization is built in, or reorder with simpler modifications.
No reviews yet. Be the first to review!
Share your experience with Schlotzsky's menu prices and value.
Your review has been submitted. It will appear shortly after approval.
Every guide for Schlotzsky's — prices, nutrition, deals, and how to order.